Spell
NormalMalefic Selector
Archetype:
Malefic
View:
3766
Banish 2 "Malefic" cards from your GY; add 2 "Malefic" cards from your Deck to your hand, except "Malefic Selector", with different names from each other and from the banished cards. You can only activate 1 "Malefic Selector" per turn.
Malefic Selector — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 52 ± 6 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 50 · Deck: 54 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Searcher / Tutor · Secondary: Combo enabler, Resource cycle
Why it scores here
Malefic Selector is a dedicated Malefic archetype tutor that cycles GY resources into hand; it appears in 80%+ of Malefic decks at 3 copies, confirming strong in-archetype consistency. However, the card generates no advantage (net 0 resources in both observed combos), enables only modest combo lines (power index 20), and provides zero disruption against opponent plays. Its mid-range score reflects essential internal synergy within its narrow archetype paired with weak board-building and external applicability.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 65 | Runs in 183 decks with 144 at 3 copies (78.7%), mostly in Malefic homes, but requires 2 Malefic cards in GY to activate. (verified) |
| Combo & Conversion | 40 | Appears in 2 combos (100% as starter) but generates 0 end-board monsters and avg power index 20, tutoring pieces rather than building tempo. (observed) |
| Resource Economy | 60 | Banishes 2, adds 2 from deck (net 0 card advantage); filters GY into hand but generates no refuel or surplus per both combo examples. (verified) |
| Effect & Interaction | 5 | Purely personal resource effect with no negation, removal, or opponent interaction whatsoever. (verified) |
| Material Utility | 0 | Normal Spell Card with no body or material utility; cannot be used as Synergy/Xyz/Link material. (verified) |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 30 | Single-use-per-turn Spell with no recursion or multi-zone value; negation ends the effect and loses the card. (verified) |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 60 | Archetype-locked to Malefic with 80%+ play in three Malefic archetypes, but minimal off-archetype adoption (Dragon Link 3.8%, Rokket 3.8%); costs a spell slot but not restrictive within home. (observed) |
Calculation
Weight profile: Primary role: Searcher/Tutor. Intrinsic ≈ 50, Deck ≈ 54, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Essential tutor for Malefic archetype consistency (80%+ inclusion across Malefic variants)
- Searches 2 distinct Malefic cards per activation, enabling piece-specific deck tuning
- 3-copy prevalence (78.7% of decks) confirms lack of garnet/brick issues
- Synergizes cleanly with core Malefic engines (99.5% co-inclusion with Paradox Gear)
Weaknesses
- Generates zero card advantage; filters GY rather than generating surplus resources
- Creates minimal combo momentum (avg power index 20 across recorded boards)
- Provides no disruption, negation, or opponent interaction
- Archetype-locked to Malefic with negligible applicability elsewhere (only 19.7% off-archetype)
Counters / choke points
- Any hand trap or negation that blocks the Normal Spell activation
- Graveyard negation/lock effects (Dimension Shifter, Macro Cosmos) prevent cost activation
- Decks running minimal Malefic monsters reduce GY resources for cost
Best use
Searcher / Tutor for Malefic piece consistency. Decks: Malefic (all variants). Suggested copies: 3.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Effect text: banish 2 Malefic from GY, add 2 different Malefic from Deck to hand; Once-per-turn activation limit confirmed; Runs in 183 total decks, 183 main-deck, 0 side-deck; 78.7% of decks run 3 copies; 14.2% run 2 copies; 7.1% run 1 copy; Appears in 100% of recorded Malefic archetype variants (3 distinct Malefic archetypes = 80.3% of total deck count); Net card advantage: 0 (banish 2, add 2)
- Observed: 100% appearance rate as starter in 2 recorded combos (highest certainty for role); Average combo power index: 20 (low; indicates minimal board-building impact); End-board composition in combos: 0 end monsters, 0 boss monsters (pure resource/hand play); Co-inclusion with Malefic cores: 99.5% with Paradox Gear, 98.4% with Stardust Dragon (strong synergy signal); Off-archetype play: Dragon Link 3.8%, Rokket 3.8%, Blue-Eyes 2.2% (limited portability); Distinct archetype count: 22 total, but 80%+ concentration in Malefic
- Inferred: Accessibility is high within Malefic given heavy GY cycling by archetype and 3-copy prevalence; Resource filtering role (GY→hand conversion) enables piece tuning rather than advantage generation; Lack of opponent interaction means it functions purely for personal consistency; Narrow archetype lock despite 22-archetype appearance (Malefic-specific text restricts generic value)
- Data gaps: Very limited combo sample (2 combos only) — thin basis for inferring broader combo potential No banlist information provided (assumed unlimited/3 copies available) Single guide mention — limited human strategic context No top-card rankings — doesn't appear in format staple lists No detailed rulings interactions documented (assumes straightforward activation/resolution)






